Leonid Nikitinsky: Recourse actions and the case of Aliya Bukina

2 April 2025

by Leonid Nikitinsky

Source: Novaya gazeta 


How citizen Bukina robbed us all – taxpayers of the Russian Federation (according to the Supreme Court). Although she could have been repaid by the prosecutors…


It would be worthwhile, of course, to go to the village of Derbisheva in the Argayash district of Chelyabinsk region to understand who, and for what reason, unleashed a whole judicial war against the head of the Derbishevsky Housing and Communal Services Department Aliya Tolgatovna Bukina. But this would be costly.

At the same time, according to the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation, it is people like citizen Bukina who are to blame for the country’s general financial distress. 

Pavel Netupsky, a journalist from St. Petersburg who regularly monitors the Justice ministry’s website, was the first to draw attention to the Supreme Court’s Ruling No. 48-KG24-26-K7 dated 10 February 2025, which then spread across networks and specialized websites. It follows from the Supreme Court’s decision that the million roubles paid to Bukina in compensation for unlawful criminal prosecution was too much, because:

Firstly, she was treated humanely. They did not remand her in custody, and all Bukina’s sufferings amounted to her suspension from work, searches at the Housing and Communal Services Department, which the whole village learned about, and dozens of hours of interrogations and court hearings.  

Secondly, (from the ruling of the Judicial Board for Civil Cases of the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation) “compensation for moral damage should ensure a balance of private and public interests so that the payment of compensation to one category of citizens would not violate the rights of other categories, since the treasury of the Russian Federation is formed by taxes, fees and payments, which are distributed and directed both towards compensation for damage caused by state bodies, as well as for the implementation of social and other programs significant to society…”

Let’s look at the points in turn: first, about the sufferings of citizen Bukina, the mother of two young children, who had the dubious honour of heading the village Housing and Communal Services Department, which, as is evident, was in a state of permanent bankruptcy.  

As can be understood from the documents of the Argayashsky district and Chelyabinsk regional courts, which Netupsky helped us discover in the Justice department’s website (not all of which are posted there), Citizen Bukina was first convicted and then acquitted of not one, but two criminal cases that developed (and fell apart) concurrently.

The first case – more precisely, fifteen episodes of charges combined into two cases – was conducted under Article 315, Part 2, of the Russian Criminal Code: “Malicious failure by a representative of the authorities, by a municipal employee, to carry out a court verdict, court decision or other judicial act.” The article is quite exotic, and from the acquittal, which stated the absence of corpus delicti, it follows that the Housing and Communal Services department and Bukina personally could not comply with the decisions of the arbitration courts to pay debts owed by the Housing and Communal Services Department for the same reason: a lack of funds. 

The second case was initiated against the background of the first case under Article 160, Part 3, of the Criminal Code — for embezzlement and misappropriation of funds entrusted to Bukina using her official position. In just two steps, according to the investigative authorities, she stole 4,120 (four thousand one hundred and twenty) roubles from the budget of the Housing and Communal Services Department, which she spent (including the bank commission) to pay the fines imposed on her in the first case.

Bukina, who as a municipal employee, declared an income in 2021 of 557,000 roubles (slightly more than 46,000 roubles per month), and possession of a house and of “vehicles — 1 pc.”, was sure she was acting lawfully, but the state prosecution insisted that ignorance of the law does not make a person exempt from accountability. 

Chelyabinsk Regional Court closed the discussion by adopting an infrequent decision to dismiss the case with reference to Article 12 of the Criminal Code: “An action (inaction) is not a crime, although it formally contains signs of an act provided for in this Code, but because of its insignificance it does not pose a public danger.” Since we have made it a rule to name the judges who impose the most cannibalistic sentences, we will also mention those who made the decision in accordance with the law and common sense. These are Chelyabinsk judges A.V. Mozhin, O.N. Tereshchenko. and S.Ya. Gladkova.  

So, the twice-acquitted citizen Bukina was granted the right to rehabilitation and applied for compensation through civil proceedings for moral damage caused to her by four years of criminal prosecution, along with the associated stress and damage to her reputation in the village.

On 12 December 2023, the Argayash district court partially upheld Bukina’s lawsuit, awarding her 1m roubles in moral damages from the Russian Ministry of Finance. This decision was upheld by both the appellate and cassation courts, but the Ministry of Finance, showing remarkable persistence, took the case to the Supreme Court. The Supreme Court, for the reasons stated above, ruled that the compensation was disproportionate and sent the case back for retrial in the Argayash court.

How much of Bukina’s blood was drained by the “law enforcement agencies” is a matter of interpretation. The question must be answered based on the priority of human rights (as enshrined in the Constitution) or the interests of the state. What deserves attention is the argument made by the Supreme Court judges (L.M. Pchelintsev, M.A. Zhubrin, and S.V. Frolkina) that Ms. Bukina had dipped her hand too deeply into the federal budget.

Given Russia’s population of 146 million, each working adult would have to chip in less than a kopeck to cover the 1m roubles awarded to Bukina – hardly something to complain about. But what seems to have been more important to the Supreme Court is the principle, expressed using well-used legal phrasing, such as that Bukina had “unjustly enriched herself,” and that as a result, pensioners and beneficiaries would be left out in the cold.

One could point to far greater unproductive expenditures for which the state reaches into our, the taxpayers’, pockets – but that’s a topic for another time.

The Supreme Court’s decision, while exaggerated to the point of self-satire, nonetheless has a kind of internal logic. However, there is a way to at least partially patch the resulting hole in the budget. It’s well known to legal professionals: a so-called recourse action claim against the party responsible for the damages reimbursed from the treasury.

The prosecutors, investigators, and detectives of the Argayash district, through their relentless persecution of Bukina, should earn the honour of compensating the Finance Ministry and paying back the rest of the Russian taxpayers – from their own wallets.

Alas, such ‘recourse’ actions are extremely rare. In 2020, Professor Nikolai Kovtun of the Nizhny Novgorod Academy of the Ministry of Internal Affairs cited figures from 2014 (more recent data could not be found). That year, the right to rehabilitation following unlawful criminal prosecution was granted to 17,644 individuals. A total of 314.6m roubles was awarded to them from the federal treasury as compensation. But only eight recourse actions were filed in court, and just two were upheld – totaling 445,000 roubles. That amounts to just 0.033 percent recovered back into the federal budget.

From the same article by Kovtun (Russian Journal of Legal Studies, No. 2, 2020), we learn that in 2018 the Legal Commission of the Russian Council of Ministers approved a bill to improve the institution of recourse actions aimed at recovering funds paid to rehabilitated individuals from those responsible. And in 2019, a bill was submitted to the State Duma that would establish minimum compensation amounts for unlawful criminal prosecution of individuals subsequently acquitted.

The fate of those bills could not be tracked – apart from the fact that none of them were passed.

From the court rulings in Aliya Bukina’s case, we learn that she did not have the money to hire a private attorney; her defence in court was handled by a court-appointed lawyer, whose services she declined. There is no comparing the resources available to a private citizen with the power of the state’s prosecutorial machine. So how can that machine be slowed down in cases like this, to achieve the equality of parties before the law and court guaranteed by the Constitution?

The threat of personal financial liability for representatives of “law enforcement agencies” might at least somewhat influence the widespread practice of unlawful prosecution – a problem that is far from limited to politically motivated cases.

But the lobbying power of these “law enforcement agencies,” which have no interest in such reforms, is far stronger than that of the Finance Ministry, not to mention human rights organisations, many of which have been crushed by those very same “agencies.”


Translated by Dominic Reed and James Lofthouse

Leave a Reply